Is ‘quoting’ a traditional culture’s art forms subject to different ethical considerations than referencing children’s art?
Yes, definitely. Children’s art, in the sense that we know it, is fairly universal and so we’re usually quoting ourselves, or the idea of ourselves, when we do it. Quoting a traditional culture’s art forms is essentially borrowing a portion or aspect of a long tradition of making that includes a great deal of practice and symbolism. Borrowing them often leads to commodification or patronization if we’re not careful. This can happen with children’s art too, but unlike children, in whose case it is appropriate to patronize, it’s imperialist and demeaning to patronize another culture. I’m not suggesting you can’t borrow without commodifying or patronizing, but you have be sensitive and specific.
What significance does the time period or particular history hold that a designer references in his or her work? Is a reference to Dutch colonization of Sub-Saharan Africa different than a reference to the Holocaust? Than a reference to the Belle Epoque or the Roaring Twenties?
A lot of times the significance of these things has to do with the attention of the culture at the time. If a designer makes Rococo wigs, it’s often in relation to, or sometimes the root of, something else going on at the time that relates to that period or symbol. Around the time Marie Antoinette came out there was a lot of correlating material in the fashion world. A reference to Dutch colonization of Sub-Saharan Africa is different from a reference to the Holocaust only in its reception, which has to do mostly with where the cultural focus is at the moment and how much is known about either issue (the details and scope of the Holocaust are much more well known for the most part than those of the colonization of Sub-Saharan Africa, despite the comparable brutality of the latter).
Monday, March 23, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment