Saturday, May 2, 2009

Course Evaluation: the Novel

Please comment on the following by noting what you found useful, or superfluous, what you think needed to be addressed more thoroughly, etc.

History of the fashion show and relationships to other performance traditions (presentation, first day)

This was pretty key. I think it expanded our expectations about the format of a fashion show to include something that didn’t even have a runway. I don’t think a lot of people understand what the runway’s for, but since we had that history we were able to understand its purpose and ways of including/excluding it.

First Day Activity: Creating a Multi Media Event in a small group, based on a theme determined by a National Geographic cover

This was fun and I got to know my group members a little better but I don’t think I took away anything really groundbreaking from it. It was nice, though.

The “Spectacle” in fashion and performance (presentation, Duggan and Evans readings (see below), journal response)

This was important, I don’t often hear about fashion from a critical theory perspective so it was nice to understand how it fits in (we covered this a lot in Fashioning Culture but this packet was concise and useful). I think it fit in well with the fashion show history. These things were especially relevant this semester because our show decidedly focused on its place in the world, and these two experiences definitely aided that.

Related readings:
• Ginger Gregg Duggan’s ““The Greatest Show on Earth: A Look at Contemporary. Fashion Shows and Their Relationship to Performance Art

It was interesting the way Duggan categorized the various types of fashion shows. The categories felt slightly arbitrary but by giving them different overarching objectives it made it easy to understand their format and decisions.

• Caroline Evans’ essay in Fashion on the Edge: Spectacle, Modernity and Deathliness

I like this book a lot. This chapter in particular was pretty much written by Guy DeBord but it has pictures!

Appropriation/Inspiration (out-of-class PowerPoint with notes, journal response)

I don't think I was quite as influenced by this, but it might have just been the circumstances. The topics addressed were quite relevant to the class and our lives and practice but unfortunately snow happened and I'm just not a compelling narrator in my head sometimes.

Visit to UMBC/Movement Exercises

I was sick for this.

Visits/Presentations by Annie Howe (Nanaprojects), Melissa Webb (Artscape/Midway), Ted Alsedek (Glitterama)

Very helpful. The most memorable part for me was when Melissa Webb and Ted Alsedek addressed how to handle performers (from a respect standpoint and an organizational standpoint). Particularly because we usually use our friends as models/performers, things can get awkward sometimes when you're trying to run a show and it's nice to have some guidelines.

Please comment on whether you would have liked the following topics to have been covered in class, and if so, how (through readings, teacher or student presentations, films etc.)?
• A Survey History of Performance Art

This would have been helpful, though I think we did okay, maybe a film or a lecture would have been nice.

• Relationship of Performance Art to other types of performance

I don't even know what to think about this, so maybe I need to know more?

• The Body in Dress History and Performance

Not necessary for this class. Better for Fashioning Culture or Costume.

Do you think that students should be required to make a dedicated body of work for this class?

I'm not really sure what this means. I think you're talking about the issue of making it a year-long class. That's the route that I took, I always thought about what I made as cumulative and I think it helped lessen my anxiety the second semester while still having something pretty interesting to present. So, it worked for me. As for everyone else, I thought that everyone in this class did a pretty good job but most people can only shell out about five piece in a semester so I think they have to consider that very carefully in their performance ideas. If they don't, the show will look REALLY boring (Kegger, for example, was a good effort, but we didn't really push the envelope that time and it was pretty boring).

Do you think more or less class time should be dedicated to the following:
Group critiques

No more, no less. We tried to do that last semester and group crits are not very useful to this class. They just make everyone hate it.

One-on-one meetings with instructor/outside critic

I think we had a good number of meetings.

Technical demonstrations (provide examples)

NO! These should be individual and provided by request. Sophomores and non-fiber majors should be encouraged to do some soul searching before joining the class. Not be mean or exclusive, but this is a huge responsibility and they owe it to themselves and everyone else in the class to have enough time and technical know-how to be able to do what they want. Madeline found a good middle ground by shortening her product line and extending her performance. If people want to learn to make clothes, they should take costume or garment construction. Not this class. Demonstrations, for more than a few people, just take up valuable class/work time. I hope that didn't sound too mean, sorry.

Presentations (i.e.: from outside professionals, etc.)

I mean, I would be opposed to more presentations but I don't find myself thinking, "wow, I wish there were more presentations in that class." I think our interaction with other members of the community was frequent and rich and presentations just don't really match that.

Field Trips (provide suggestions.)

I'm not sure. I really really love field trips but this class is such a time commitment that I'm hesitant to argue for more.

The Journal:
I asked you to keep a journal (in the form of a book or blog) in which to collect visual inspiration, sketches, notes, reflections and research. My reason for making the journal a required part of the class is because 1) I believe that it is a helpful technique for thinking through problems and recording your creative process and 2) unless explicitly required, journaling often falls by the wayside. What is your perspective on this? I.e.: did you find it helpful to be asked to keep a journal or blog? Do you have any suggestions regarding this aspect of the class?

The journal was reassuring. I didn't use it very much for most of the semester but when I got so stressed out that I started to question why I was even making what I was making, it was nice to know that there was a place in cyberspace where my thoughts were organized and researched. I'm glad it was required.

Objectives:
After your experience in this class, what do you think the goals or objectives of this class should be? (i.e.: to provide students with a professional development opportunity in designing and producing an event, to create a line of garments, to equip students with an understanding of historical, theoretical and practical issues surrounding fashion, costume and performance.) I recognize that a class can have multiple objectives, but given limited time and resources available, certain goals will take precedence. Please list at least three objectives for the Multi Media Event starting with the most important from your perspective.

1. making an event and conceptualizing a body of work related to a group performance
2. fashion's relationship to art and the world (and its very loose definition/s).
3. making the community better off: it was important for me that Brouhaha was a symbiotic relationship between the market and the class, Station North and MICA, our class and the models/musicians/technicians, etc. Kegger didn't feel important, it felt like a display for the school. This was much more fulfilling.

The Event/Event Planning:
Please reflect on the following aspects of the work leading up to Brouhaha, commenting on aspects you thought were helpful or effective, frustrating, confusing or counter-productive.

Initial brainstorming to come up with a name for the event: (using silent techniques, posting ideas on the board, process of elimination, etc.)

This went so much quicker than Kegger!! I have absolutely no complaints.

Writing and keeping a workplan:

I'm embarassed that I didn't do this earlier. Thank you for making me do this.

Being involved in decisions regarding the event and class budget:

I appreciate being included. I also appreciate being given a copy, not only does it display transparency but it's helpful for planning events in the future.

Process for choosing teams (writing a paragraph about your choices in advance, posting first and second choice in class.)

I guess this process is always a little muddy. It still felt muddy, despite being organized, but I'm glad people stuck to their teams this time. It made everyone accountable.

Rehearsals (more, less? Format? How to accommodate participanting performers/models needs better)

The rehearsal schedule was the rehearsal schedule because it was managable. I think it's unreasonable to get more than three out of all the models at one time, but I'm pretty sure all the designers held private rehearsals. So as long as people promise to hold private rehearsals three is sufficient.

Also, I think we should give some serious thought to providing food as a class on the day of the show, even if it doesn't come out of the class budget. I was totally unable to do anything but order pizza, which was late. Plus, having modeled in these situations before, I like it better when the different camps are forced to interact with each other.

The class requires a significant commitment of time outside of class from you, as well as participants. I endeavored to give you time in class to work on aspects of event planning. This took time away from substantive discussions about ideas and issues surrounding fashion, costume, and performance, as well as demos and worktime. How do you feel about this aspect of the class?

This class is a massive responsibility. I look at it like the practical partner to Fashioning Culture, where we did nothing but discuss ideas and issues surrounding fashion, costume and performance (and the media, and whatever else we had on our minds that day...). In order for this event to have been fully functional, we really did need all of that time for everyone to brainstorm and get on the same page and make decisions together. If it had all been worktime or conceptual discussions we wouldn't have learned as much about what it takes to put on an event together. Plus, I never felt like I was cheated on worktime.

Do you have any suggestions or ideas for making sure that the work for the event is more equally divided among students?

Not at this time but I'll edit this post if I think of some.

The stated outcomes for the Multi Media Event were to create a multimedia event that would showcase the work of students in the class. We talked about how every event has unintended outcomes. Could you please describe below what other outcomes and learning experiences this class provided that you did not foresee? i.e.: Did the class affect your interest in performance? Collaboration? Professional fields that interest you? Your sense of confidence? Your friendships with people? Your communication skills? Etc.

I guess the most valuable thing I got out of it was the discovery that I actually do have the talent for time management (sometimes). I also learned that understudies are a good idea when working with a lot of busy people. I also learned that I absolutely love working with stretchwear and printing textiles on the body. I always knew I liked to perform, but this experience reinforced that feeling as well.

In summary, if you had to define the two most valuable aspects of this class (course and event), what would they be:

Again, time management and the confidence boost I got out of making and choreographing everything.

If you had to name the two most challenging or frustrating aspects of this class (course and event) what would they be? Do you have any ideas or solutions to these challenges?

As far as the event, organizing the rehearsals was a total nightmare sometimes. I had to commandeer my friends' apartment a couple times (only one of them had told me I could use it so it was a surprise for the other six) and people forgot, were late, etc... and I was trying to explain everything without music. That wasn't fun.

In the class, sometimes I felt a little left out by my group and then I felt like a slacker. I don't think they meant for that to happen, it just sort of did.

I feel like both of these things have pretty obvious solutions so I'm not going to offer suggestions other than experience.

Ideas for Next Year:
I am considering requiring Multi Media Event to be a year-long course (ie: students would have to be enrolled for Fall and Spring semesters.) The first semester would cover content in the first semester (including several presentations/discussions and readings, field trips, experimentation with performance and site design etc.) The first semester would culminate in a small, informal performance or recital on campus (perhaps for invited guests only) to play around with performance and staging ideas. The event would take place between late February and early March. Follow up after the event would include teams working on short projects such as a CD of the soundtrack, a catalogue or website, a workshop etc. Please comment on these ideas:

That sounds like a great idea. I'm sad that I won't be here for it. I'm not sure about the CD, I guess I'm not sure what you have in mind. I like the catalogue idea and I'm excited for the new pace of the class, I hope it goes well. I think it will be much less stressful than our experience.

I am considering asking the market to host the event again next year, and using many of the same team players (lighting and musicians, etc.) This would limit the choice making of students in the class regarding many elements of the class, but also would liberate students to spend more time working on other aspects of the event, such as site design/staging, choreography as well as engaging with content (performance history, films etc.) What do you think about this? (Keeping the event at the Market vs. finding another raw space and community of people to work with).

I feel guilty because after learning that most people didn't understand that there was live music, and after seeing how EXHAUSTED Dave, Domenica and Zach were I feel like they didn't get a lot out of it in the end. I haven't talked to them about it so I don't know how they feel but if they're included next year I think they need some other for of recognition or recompense.

As to the space, I really like the market and I think they'd be thrilled to host it again but I'm wondering whether there are some (free) spaces elsewhere in the city that need the aid of the mighty Brouhaha?

Please use the space below to make any other comments regarding this class, my instruction/facilitation, and/or to share ideas. Thank you again for your honesty and for taking the time to thoughtfully reflect on and respond to this course evaluation.

I had a fun time this semester and I learned a lot. You seem to really be in your element teaching this class and I'm very happy we had an instructor/facilitator as patient, encouraging and organized as you are. I think the event needs to be more publicized in the future or just take pains to point out that it's NOT the MICA fashion show.

Thanks for a great year, Valeska!